Is there anything that gets you more hyped for fantasy baseball than the Fantasy Alarm staff dropping in its fantasy baseball bold predictions for the 2025 MLB season? Probably not. 

So, we’ve decided to cap off our award-winning Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide and draft season in just that fashion, with 15 fantasy baseball analysts, including GM Jim Bowden, planting their flags across the baseball season.

 

 

 

Now, don’t confuse “bold” with irrational. We’re not about that, nor should you be. Anyone can make a bunch of haphazard guesses, but if you don’t have the facts or the data to back them up, what good are they?

For these MLB bold predictions, the research has been done. Assessments have been made. Bets have been placed. We don’t guess. We make our picks actionable items. So, let’s just get right to it!

**All odds courtesy of DraftKings Sportsbook

Fantasy Baseball Bold Predictions: MLB 2025

 Howard BenderJim BowdenJon ImpembaColby ConwayMatt Selz
Twitter Handle@rotobuzzguy@JimBowdenGM@jimpemba777@colbyrconway@theselzman
AL MVPBobby WittBobby WittBobby Witt JrBobby Witt JrBobby Witt Jr
NL MVPKyle TuckerShohei OhtaniElly De La CruzElly De La CruzFrancisco Lindor
AL Cy YoungCole RagansGarrett CrochetGarrett CrochetLogan GilbertGarrett Crochet
NL Cy YoungDylan CeaseZack WheelerPaul SkenesPaul SkenesCorbin Burnes
AL ROYJackson JobeJackson JobeRoman AnthonyJasson DominguezJackson Jobe
NL ROYMatt ShawDylan CrewsRoki SasakiDylan CrewsMatt Shaw
200 K first timeTanner BibeeHunter BrownPaul SkenesHunter BrownPaul Skenes
30 saves first timeJhoan DuranMason MillerTanner ScottAndres MunozMason Miller
30 HR first timeShea LangeliersMark VientosElly De La CruzMark VientosMark Vientos
30 SB first timeOneil CruzAnthony VolpePete Crow-ArmstrongDylan CrewsJake McCarthy
20/20 first timeWyatt LangfordLawrence ButlerJazz ChisholmMatt McLainLawrence Butler
.300 first timeMichael HarrisJackson ChourioJackson MerrillMichael HarrisJung Hoo Lee
Cheap source HRPaul DeJongJake BurgerMichael TogliaHunter GoodmanJorge Soler
Cheap source SBLane ThomasMaikel GarciaBrice TurangVictor RoblesJacob Young
Cheap source KsSpencer ArrighettiBrandon PfaadtMacKenzie GoreHayden BirdsongMacKenzie Gore
Cheap source SVsPorter HodgeJesus TinocoAroldis ChapmanCarlos EstevezKyle Finnegan
Fail to Match the HypeWilly AdamesLuis ArraezJames WoodKetel MarteMichael Harris
Exceeds ExpectationsNolan JonesMatt WallnerMatt McLainPete Crow-ArmstrongOneil Cruz
Must OwnMatt McLainShohei OhtaniBryce MillerJosh LoweConnor Norby
Oh Hell NoJacob deGromRandy ArozarenaWilly AdamesJacob deGromJuan Soto
Favorite Futures BetJarren Duran most 2B (+700)Rangers win AL West (+225)Elly De La Cruz 30+ HR (+175)Dylan Crews 30+ SB (+155)Royals OVER 82.5 Wins
      
 Josh WagnerJoe GallinaHenry WilsonDan MalinRyan Kirksey
Twitter Handle@JWaggs10@joegallina@Henry13Wilson13@RealDANlanta@CableBoxScore
AL MVPBobby Witt JrBobby WittJose RamirezBobby WittBobby Witt
NL MVPShohei OhtaniShohei OhtaniElly De La CruzShohei OhtaniJuan Soto
AL Cy YoungGarrett CrochetTarik SkubalGarrett CrochetGarrett CrochetLogan Gilbert
NL Cy YoungPaul SkenesSpencer SchwellenbachPaul SkenesZack WheelerPaul Skenes
AL ROYJackson JobeJasson DominguezKristian CampbellJasson DominguezKristian Campbell
NL ROYDylan CrewsDylan CrewsRoki SasakiDylan CrewsDylan Crews
200 K first timePaul SkenesPaul SkenesSpencer SchwellenbachPaul SkenesPaul Skenes
30 saves first timeJhoan DuranMason MillerAndres MunozMason MillerRyan Walker
30 HR first timeElly De La CruzMark VientosShea LangeliersJarren DuranJunior Caminero
30 SB first timeOneil CruzJackson ChourioPete Crow-ArmstrongWyatt LangfordPete Crow-Armstrong
20/20 first timeMatt ShawLawrence ButlerLawrence ButlerLawrence ButlerPete Crow-Armstrong
.300 first timeKyle TuckerJackson MerrillJackson MerrillCorbin CarrollMichael Harris
Cheap source HRTriston CasasJake BurgerBrandon LoweJoc PedersonJake Burger
Cheap source SBJacob YoungBryson StottJacob YoungJacob YoungAndres Gimenez
Cheap source KsYusei KikuchiMacKenzie GoreJose SorianoNick LodoloHunter Brown
Cheap source SVsAroldis ChapmanRyan PresslyKyle FinneganKyle FinneganColin Holderman
Fail to Match the HypeJose AltuveClay HolmesWyatt LangfordChris SaleRoki Sasaki
Exceeds ExpectationsSeiya SuzukiBo BichetteZebby MatthewsJake McCarthyLane Thomas
Must OwnJarren DuranMookie BettsSpencer SchwellenbachOneil CruzEzequiel Tovar
Oh Hell NoRandy ArozarenaLuis RobertHunter GreeneJacob deGromJacob deGrom
Favorite Futures BetRangers OVER 85.5 WinsRed Sox OVER 86.5 winsYankees UNDER 90 winsMax Fried - Most Wins (+4000)Astros OVER 84.5 wins
      
 Ivar AndersonJames GrandeAidan GaulDan ServodidioAndrew Cooper
Twitter Handle@johnwhorfin@The_Real_Grande@AidanG_FBB@dan_servodidio@CoopAFiasco
AL MVPBobby Witt, Jr.Corey SeagerBobby WittJose RamirezJose Ramirez
NL MVPJuan SotoCorbin CarrollCorbin CarrollShohei OhtaniMookie Betts
AL Cy YoungGarrett CrochetPablo LopezCole RagansTarik SkubalLogan Gilbert
NL Cy YoungZack WheelerYoshinobu YamamotoPaul SkenesZack WheelerPaul Skenes
AL ROYCoby MayoKristian CampbellCam SmithRoman AnthonyRoman Anthony
NL ROYDylan CrewsMatt ShawRoki SasakiMatt ShawDylan Crews
200 K first timeMacKenzie GoreTanner BibeeJoe RyanHunter GreeneHunter Greene
30 saves first timeJhoan DuranTrevor MegillMason MillerTrevor MegillJustin Martinez
30 HR first timeMichael TogliaKerry CarpenterJackson ChourioJake BurgerWyatt Langford
30 SB first timePete Crow-ArmstrongOtto LopezMichael HarrisAnthony VolpeJackson Chourio
20/20 first timeAnthony VolpeMatt ChapmanHeliot RamosBryson StottWyatt Langford
.300 first timeKyle TuckerJackson MerrillMatt McLainJarren DuranJarren Duran
Cheap source HRTyler SoderstromJorge SolerJake BurgerRhys HoskinsCarlos Santana
Cheap source SBSal FrelickVictor RoblesJung Hoo LeeJose CaballeroVictor Robles
Cheap source KsJesus LuzardoHayden BirdsongSandy AlcantaraHayden BirdsongMatthew Boyd
Cheap source SVsAroldis ChapmanKyle FinneganCarlos EstevezRyan PresslyJustin Martinez
Fail to Match the HypeWilly AdamesJordan WestburgJasson DominguezGarrett CrochetJasson Dominguez
Exceeds ExpectationsDrake BaldwinMatt ChapmanJackson HollidayJesus LuzardoEloy Jimenez
Must OwnBobby Witt, Jr.Matt ShawAdley RutschmanMarcus SemienMike Trout
Oh Hell NoMike TroutJhoan DuranJacob deGromJacob deGromMax Scherzer
Favorite Futures BetJackson Jobe AL ROY (+900)Matt Shaw NL ROY (+425)Reds Win NL Central (+650)Tigers Win AL Central (+270)Mariners OVER 84.5 wins