Looking for the best NFL player prop picks today for Week 1's Sunday Night Football finale? The Cowboys and Giants close out the opening slate with a classic NFC East rivalry game, and it's loaded with storylines on both sidelines. Below, we break down our top Cowboys vs. Giants player props, complete with the lines and the matchup context behind each play.

 

Best NFL Sunday Week 1 Player Prop Picks

Dak Prescott and the Cowboys head to MetLife Stadium to face a Giants team with plenty of fresh faces of its own, from new head coach John Harbaugh to a quarterback in Jaxson Dart who flashed real promise as a rookie. Prescott is coming off arguably the best statistical season of his career, while Dart's legs were the story of his first year under center. Here are the props we like best for this Week 1 finale.

Cowboys vs. Giants Player Props: Jaxson Dart Over 31.5 Rushing Yards

Dart's rookie season was defined by his legs as much as his arm, averaging 34.8 rushing yards per game across his 12 starts and finishing with 487 yards and nine touchdowns on the ground. He was tied for the best third-down EPA per attempt by a rookie quarterback since 2020, largely because of his willingness to extend plays and pick up yardage with his feet. New head coach John Harbaugh and offensive coordinator Matt Nagy have a track record of building around a mobile quarterback, and there's no reason to think that identity changes in year two. In the two teams' meeting last season, Dart already cleared this number with 32 rushing yards in a season-ending win over Dallas, and there's a lot to like about him doing it again in the rematch.

Cowboys vs. Giants Player Prop Bets: Javonte Williams Anytime TD

Williams turned in a career year in his first season in Dallas, rushing for 1,201 yards and 11 touchdowns while locking down the Cowboys' RB1 job by a wide margin. The team rewarded him with a three-year extension this offseason, and nothing about his workload or role near the goal line figures to change entering Week 1. New York also traded away run-stopping anchor Dexter Lawrence to the Bengals this offseason, leaving a young and still-developing front seven for Williams to run against. A proven, high-volume goal-line back facing a defensive front that's still finding its identity is a strong recipe for finding the end zone.

Sunday Night Football Player Props: Isaiah Likely Over 3.5 Receptions

Likely followed John Harbaugh from Baltimore to New York this offseason on a three-year, $40 million deal, and for the first time in his career he steps in as a true No. 1 tight end rather than sharing the room with a bigger name. His four years with the Ravens showed real playmaking ability, and he now inherits a featured role in an offense that Harbaugh and Nagy are building around multiple tight end sets, a staple of their time together in Baltimore. Dart also showed real chemistry with his tight ends during his rookie year, and Likely projects as an every-down piece of the passing game from Week 1 on. Clearing 3.5 receptions in his Giants debut as the clear top target at the position looks very reasonable.

Cowboys vs. Giants Player Prop Bets: Dak Prescott Over 1.5 Passing TDs

Prescott put together one of the best seasons of his career in 2025, throwing for 4,552 yards and 30 touchdowns behind a receiving corps that returns fully intact in CeeDee Lamb, George Pickens, and Jake Ferguson. He's already shown in camp that he's picked up right where he left off, and a Giants defense breaking in new pieces after trading away Dexter Lawrence gives him a favorable matchup to keep that momentum going. Multiple passing touchdowns has been the baseline expectation for Prescott whenever he's been healthy and surrounded by this much talent, and there's little reason to expect a letdown in a rivalry opener. Clearing 1.5 passing scores against a Giants defense still finding its footing feels like the right side.

How to bet on NFL Week 1 Sunday Player Props at Novig Sportsbook & Claim Your Spend $10, Get $25 Bonus with promo code ALARM

New users can back any of these Cowboys vs. Giants player prop picks at Novig Sportsbook and unlock a Spend $10, Get $25 Bonus offer using promo code ALARM. Sign up, make a qualifying $10 deposit and wager, and the bonus lands in the account automatically, no waiting on rollover requirements before getting started. It's a straightforward way to add extra plays around a Week 1 finale already loaded with value on both sides.