NFL Pool Picks Week 1: Strategy for Pick’em & Confidence Pools

Week 1 of the NFL season always feels like a fresh start. Every entry is alive, the public is overreacting to offseason headlines, and pool players everywhere are searching for an edge. The challenge is knowing how aggressive to be and where the true value lies.

The right strategy depends on the type of NFL pool you’re playing in. Below, we’ll break down smart approaches for Pick’em pools, Confidence pools, and weekly prize formats by showing you where the public may be leaving value on the table and how you can leverage that information.

Get Your NFL Pool Edge Today:

Season-Long Pick’em: Start Steady

In season-long NFL Pick’em contests, where the champion is crowned based on total correct picks across 18 weeks, Week 1 is not the time to swing for the fences. The best play is usually to lean on favorites, limit risk, and focus on building a foundation for the long haul.

Of course, that doesn’t mean you should simply follow the crowd every week. The key is spotting undervalued teams that the public is ignoring despite solid win odds (we’ll get to that in a bit). That’s where you can separate yourself early without jeopardizing survival.

 

 

 

Confidence Pools: Anchor with Favorites, Target Mispriced Games

Confidence pools add another layer of complexity. Not only do you have to pick winners, but you must also rank each matchup by assigning points. The right strategy? Anchor your top slots with the biggest favorites, then search for leverage in the middle.

Here are two examples in Week 1 where the public is underrating the favorite:

  • Green Bay (-2.5 vs. Detroit): Despite being favored at home, fewer than 25% of entries are backing the Packers. That disconnect between betting markets and pick popularity creates a value opportunity.
     
  • Indianapolis (-1.5 vs. Miami): The Colts are also being overlooked, with under 25% of players taking them, even though their true win odds are slightly better than a coin flip.

These are exactly the kinds of undervalued spots that give you separation in confidence pools. One or two of these plays each week can swing entire leaderboards.

Where To Get Public Pick Data

Wondering where to find accurate public pick data? PoolGenius collects and updates this information from major pool hosting sites. That means you can see exactly where the crowd is leaning — and just as importantly, where they’re overlooking value.

Get Your NFL Pool Edge Today:

Weekly Prize Pools: Go Contrarian

In weekly prize formats, the goal isn’t just to survive, it’s to beat the entire field in a single slate. That means leaning into contrarian underdogs with realistic chances to pull off an upset.

Week 1 has several live dogs being picked by less than 25% of the public:

  • Chicago (vs. Minnesota)
  • Atlanta (vs. Tampa Bay)
  • Houston (at LA Rams)
  • NY Jets (vs. Pittsburgh)
  • Seattle (vs. San Francisco)

Nailing just a couple of these gives you the leverage needed to contend for a weekly prize. Another high-upside spot: Baltimore at Buffalo (Pick’em), where the Bills are drawing heavy public support. Fading that popularity could pay off.

 

 

 

Smarter NFL Pool Picks in 2025

At the end of the day, winning NFL pools isn’t about guesswork; it’s about stacking the odds in your favor. The challenge is keeping up with all the data: win probabilities, pick popularity, expected value, and future matchups.

That’s where PoolGenius comes in. Their NFL Pool Picks Tool gathers public pick data from major hosting sites, compares it with betting markets, and shows you exactly where to stay safe or go against the grain based on your pool’s size and rules.

Get Your NFL Pool Edge Today:

FREE TRIAL: Try all products risk-free