Looking to build a winning card for the May 12 MLB slate? We are identifying the sharpest value on the board by comparing current MLB DFS Projections against recent performance trends and lineup K-rates to find the best Underdog MLB Picks. Today’s board features some of the highest-upside young arms in the game, including Paul Skenes and Will Warren. Be sure to track all our movements on the Fantasy Alarm Bet Tracker to see our full board of expert picks.

Paul Skenes MLB Underdog Fantasy Pick: Higher than 7.5 Strikeouts

Paul Skenes is a primary target for Underdog MLB Picks today. His effectiveness is supported by a 28.9% strikeout rate and a 9.9 K/9. Today, he draws a Colorado Rockies lineup that ranks as the #5 strikeout target in the majors (24.4% K-rate vs RHP). Our MLB DFS Projections indicate that Skenes' ability to overpower contact-prone hitters makes this a high-upside spot for punchouts. When building your card with Underdog MLB Picks, Skenes offers one of the highest strikeout ceilings on the slate.

 

 

 

Will Warren MLB Underdog Fantasy Pick: Higher than 5.5 Strikeouts

Will Warren is another elite value according to our latest MLB DFS Projections. Warren has been missing bats at a massive frequency, sporting a 30.5% strikeout rate and an 11.4 K/9, while clearing this 5.5 line in 6 of 8 starts this season. He faces a Baltimore Orioles unit that strikes out at the 4th highest rate in the league against righties (24.4%). We are taking the Higher on Warren as he looks to exploit a high-variance Baltimore order, making him a cornerstone for today's Underdog MLB Picks. Using accurate MLB DFS Projections is key to finding value on high-whiff arms like Warren.

Unlock Your $50 Guaranteed Bonus & More With Underdog Promo

Ready to lock in these Underdog MLB Picks? Use promo code ALARM at sign-up to unlock your exclusive welcome offer and gain access to all our high-level MLB DFS Projections.

FeatureUnderdog Offer Details
Promo CodeALARM
Welcome BonusPlay $5, Get $75 Instantly + Special Pick
Verified DateMay 12, 2026
Claim OfferClick Here to Sign Up