Dustin May Underdog MLB Picks Today, 4/27: Baseball Projections + More

Quick Summary of Today's Top Underdog Picks:

• Max Fried (NYY): Higher than 5.5 Strikeouts 
• Dustin May (STL): Lower than 4.5 Strikeouts 

Looking to find the edge for your Monday night card? The Underdog Fantasy board for April 27, 2026, features a mix of high-upside veterans and arms returning to form. As we navigate the early-season split data, we are focusing on two righties and lefties with vastly different paths to production. Stay ahead of the field by using our data-driven player projections to navigate today's daily rotation changes.

Max Fried Underdog MLB Pick: Higher than 5.5 Strikeouts

Max Fried is stepping into what might be the best matchup of the entire night for a southpaw. While Fried has split his six starts on the over/under this season, he is coming off a season-best nine-strikeout performance against the Red Sox. Even though his overall strikeout numbers have been a bit down this year, that last outing proved the high-end ceiling is still very much intact. He faces a Texas Rangers lineup that has been absolutely lost against lefties this year, ranking 1st in the majors with a 29.7 percent strikeout rate. Fried has the command to exploit their aggressiveness, and he only needs six punchouts to clear this projection.

Dustin May Underdog MLB Pick: Lower than 4.5 Strikeouts

Dustin May continues his return to form, but the strikeout volume simply hasn't been there yet. He has stayed lower than this 4.5 line in four of his five starts this season, and even his season-best five-strikeout performance in his last outing only cleared it by a hook. The matchup today is particularly challenging as the Pirates boast a lefty-heavy lineup tonight with Oneil Cruz, Nathaniel Lowe, Ryan O'Hearn, and Spencer Horwitz. May has historically struggled against left-handed hitters, allowing a massive .625 slugging percentage and a .391 average to lefties. Combined with a meager 15.2 percent strikeout rate in that split, May is more likely to give us another "pitched-to-contact" performance than a high-whiff outing.

Click here to claim your Play $5, Get $75 bonus at Underdog Fantasy with promo code ALARM now!