MLB Home Run Picks Today: Best Home Run Predictions for September 9th, 2026
Tonight may feature the very first NFL game of the season, but with afternoon baseball leading up to the Patriots vs. Seahawks Super Bowl rematch, why not enjoy some MLB home run picks? We cashed in with Will Smith last night and now have the ability to cash in big before watching the unique Wednesday Night Football action. With plenty of worthy targets, we’re here to get you set for it all. Furthermore, there are just five games on the diamond tomorrow, so yes, we really do need to take advantage of some MLB home run predictions for today!
You’ll also want to check out the best fantasy sports promo codes from the top legal sites in your state. Make sure that you also crush your MLB DFS contests today with our DFS Playbook, Starting Lineups, Lineup Generator & DFS Tools!
⚾ Top MLB Home Run Picks for Today
We got three top aces out of the way last night with Cam Schlittler, Jacob Misiorowski, and Tarik Skubal, but we still have guys like Cristopher Sanchez and Logan Henderson standing in our way of top MLB home run picks. Thankfully, you can still enjoy those guys on the mound with our MLB expert picks. You can also swap sports to see our NFL Week 1 picks! Regardless, if you’re still just worried about MLB home run predictions over football, then utilize our exclusive MLB home run prop tool!
🔥 Best Matchups for Home Runs Today, 9/9: Ballpark Factors & Weather Impact
Prior to the transition day tomorrow, we have four afternoon games in California/Seattle, so before locking in any MLB home run picks, it’s all about our MLB weather report. Once we know what’s going on with wind, humidity, and more, we can start breaking down pitchers. That means righty/lefty splits, slugging and ISO allowed, pitch mixes, and more.
As for hitters, it’s much the same metrics, which include others like barrel rates, hard-hit rates, average exit velocities, and more. Speaking of “more,” we also have to consider bullpens, as we can’t expect only starters to allow MLB home run picks to cash. After adding it all up, here’s why we’ve come up with our top three targets.
Ben Rice (+257)
He’s back, back again - Tomoyuki Sugano! He’s back on the mound tonight, and while it’s not at Coors Field, Yankee Stadium is quite friendly to dingers as well. We also can’t forget that it’s the Colorado Rockies bullpen coming in behind him, and oh yeah - Aaron Judge is back! So, how could we NOT start with Rockies vs. Yankees with our top MLB home run picks today?
When it comes to Sugano, both sides of the plate go yard, and frankly, New York could use tonight to call up some minor league guys. The Rockies righty has a .476 slugging allowed to righties and .576 to lefties. As much as we want to take Aaron Judge (he has terrible odds, by the way), we’re going to stick with southpaws, as they also have a whopping .301 ISO against Sugano.
Luis Garcia, Jr. is the clear pivot here, but we’re leading off our best MLB home run picks today with Ben Rice hitting a HR (28%, so +257, at Novig).
Max Muncy (+400)
We’re going coast-to-coast and from one monster sports market to the other by going from the Bronx to LA. It was Dodgers catcher Will Smith who smashed a round-tripper for us last night, and now their star-studded lineup gets to face Rhett Lowder. Interestingly enough, Smith may not even be in the lineup at all to cash more MLB home run picks!
That’s with Lowder not being a lefty, but what he does do is allow massive power to lefties at the plate. When facing the Dodgers, that’s about as rough as it gets - well, as great as it gets for us. Much like taking Aaron Judge in his return is extremely tempting, the same could be said for Shohei Ohtani finally hitting another one after his brief time out of the lineup.
He is the very obvious pivot, but let’s enjoy a more valuable payout for a guy with .239 ISO vs. righties and add to our best MLB home run picks today with Max Muncy hitting a HR (+400 at FanDuel).
Mickey Gasper (+575)
This final spot should be reserved for Diamondbacks vs. Royals, even with these weird games with no runs until late recently. However, with the highest chance of rain here, we won’t risk giving you a name that doesn’t play. So, as you can see, we’re focusing on the Angels vs. Red Sox matchup to continue our top MLB home run picks today.
It’s one where we recently had Roman Anthony as a target, and while he let us down, the Boston lineup gets to enjoy righty Ryan Johnson starting, and of course, the LA bullpen. We would love if Willson Contreras was in the lineup with that being the case but let’s enjoy Gasper’s crazy splits - a great .551 slugging vs. righties, but .095 vs. lefties!
Along with a .254 ISO vs. righties, let’s round out our best MLB home run picks for today with the value spot of Mickey Gasper hitting a HR (+575 at bet365).
🎯 Newsletter Exclusive Pick 🎯
Our top home run picks are above, but we also included one bonus HR play exclusively in today's edition of The Daily Alarm. If you're subscribed, don't forget to check your inbox before lock. If not, sign up for free to get these extra and exclusive picks daily!
🚀 Longshot Home Run Picks Today
Our FREE newsletter bonus picks have treated us well the past couple of weeks to pair with our top three MLB home run picks being awesome all season. However, let’s keep the value coming with a longshot option for today…
Again, Tomoyuki Sugano is on the mound, so how could we not circle back to Yankee Stadium? Well, because of that, the longest odds for anyone on NY is around +640 (George Lombard), but the Rockies can rock Will Warren as well. You know how much we love Jake McCarthy, but since he homered last time we pivoted away, we’ll pull a double move and not do what you’d expect - we’re taking the third baseman’s recent return and his 99th percentile launch-angle sweet-spot percentage as our best MLB home run longshot pick for today!
💲 Today’s Best MLB Home Run Parlay
As for an even juicier potential payout, let’s go a step further than that longshot spot. Let’s do it with multiple MLB home run picks creating a for-fun parlay…
A trio of lefties with a way to get them with much more value than their individual price tags - although Anthony has a juicy one to begin with. Either way, let’s take advantage and cash all the MLB home run picks above!
