Looking for the best NFL TNF player prop picks for Week 11? The 3-7 Colts visit the 3-6 Texans on Thursday night with Houston a 12.5-point favorite and the total set at 44.5. Below, we break down our top Colts vs. Texans player props, complete with the lines and the matchup context behind each play.
Best NFL Thursday Night Football Player Prop Picks
Both teams are fighting for an AFC South lifeline, with Houston needing a win to stay alive in the playoff race and Indianapolis coming off its first victory since Week 4. The Colts rank 31st in rush defense DVOA and 23rd in pass defense DVOA, while the Texans bring a pass rush with 33 sacks. Here are the props we like best for Thursday night.
Colts vs. Texans Player Props: C.J. Stroud Over 1.5 Passing TDs
Stroud has been on a tear, throwing three or more touchdown passes in back-to-back games for the first time in his career, including five against the Chargers (384 yards) and three against Cleveland (211 yards) in last week's 27-24 loss. He has 19 touchdown passes in nine games, an average of 2.1 per game, with multiple touchdowns in at least five of them, and he is averaging 274.3 passing yards per game. Indianapolis ranks 23rd in pass defense DVOA and 31st against WR2 and is reportedly missing its top two cornerbacks, while Houston has allowed just 17 sacks and committed only five giveaways, both among the league's best. The Texans are 12.5-point home favorites with an implied total near 28.5, a script that should produce touchdowns even if the ground game stays quiet. Cleveland pressured him on 54.8% of his dropbacks, so protection can matter, but clearing 1.5 touchdown passes looks like a good bet at home against the Colts.
Colts vs. Texans Player Prop Bets: Daniel Jones Over 0.5 Interceptions
Jones has thrown 12 interceptions in 10 starts, with multiple picks in four games, including two in last week's 24-22 win over Miami in which he went 11 of 22 for 108 yards. He now faces a Houston defense with 33 sacks (3.67 per game) and 19 takeaways, and Indianapolis may be missing both starting offensive tackles after trading receivers Keenan Allen and Josh Downs at the deadline. The Colts are 12.5-point underdogs, so Jones should be asked to throw more than he did against Miami, and Houston ranks 12th overall in defensive DVOA. He could be pulled in a blowout, which is the main risk, but a quarterback with this turnover rate against this pass rush makes over 0.5 interceptions look like a good bet.
Thursday Night Football Player Props: David Montgomery Over 14.5 Rushing Attempts
Montgomery is expected back from the groin injury that sidelined him for four straight games, as he practiced in full on Tuesday while fellow back Woody Marks (concussion) did not practice Monday or Tuesday. He has had only one 15-carry game this season, 20 carries and three touchdowns in Week 1, and he is averaging just 2.7 yards per carry on 52 carries for 138 yards, so the volume question is real. But Houston is a 12.5-point favorite, Indianapolis ranks 31st in rush defense DVOA and 22nd against running backs, and if Marks is unavailable, Montgomery would be the lead back in a script that favors running late. Marks has had at least 15 carries in each of his last four games, so the split matters, and this is a bet on Montgomery's workload if Houston's top back is limited.
Colts vs. Texans Player Prop Bets: Jonathan Taylor Under 53.5 Rushing Yards
Taylor leads the Colts with 739 rushing yards and eight touchdowns on 177 carries, but he has not had a 100-yard game this season and averages just 4.2 yards per carry. Houston held him to 68 yards on 23 carries (3.0 per carry) in the first meeting, and the Texans rank 11th in rush defense DVOA with a pass rush that has produced 33 sacks. Indianapolis is a 12.5-point underdog that may be missing both starting tackles, and rookie Seth McGowan took 12 carries last week while cutting into red-zone work, so Taylor's volume could be limited if the Colts trail. He has topped 90 yards five times, so this is a bet against his 73.9-yard season average, and a run-heavy offense after the deadline trades works against the under, but the game script and the matchup point to a lower number.
How to bet on NFL Week 11 Thursday Night Football Player Props at Novig Sportsbook & Claim Your Spend $10, Get $25 Bonus with promo code ALARM
New users can back any of these Colts vs. Texans player prop picks at Novig Sportsbook and unlock a Spend $10, Get $25 Bonus offer using promo code ALARM. Sign up, make a qualifying $10 deposit and wager, and the bonus lands in the account automatically, no waiting on rollover requirements before getting started. It's a straightforward way to add extra plays around a Thursday night matchup already loaded with value on both sides.
