Right-hander Sonny Gray and the Minnesota Twins are in agreement on a two-year, $55 million contract that includes an opt-out after the first season, ESPN's Jeff Passan reports. Gray, 37, returns to the club he pitched for in 2022 and 2023, after going 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA for the Red Sox in 2026 and declining his side of a mutual option. The agreement had not been officially announced when it was reported on Wednesday, November 18.

Sonny Gray Contract Details

PlayerRHP Sonny Gray, 37
TeamMinnesota Twins (from the Boston Red Sox)
ContractTwo years, $55 million (about $27.5 million per year)
Opt-outGray can opt out after the first season (2027)
Draft pick impactNone. Gray is ineligible for a qualifying offer because he received one in 2023
StatusAgreement reported by ESPN's Jeff Passan; not yet officially announced

Terms per ESPN's Jeff Passan. The year-by-year salary split and the exact structure of the opt-out had not been reported at publication.

The deal lands right where the market expected. The Athletic projected Gray at roughly $55 million over two seasons, and MLB Trade Rumors' Steve Adams predicted two years and $55 million as well, noting that Gray's age would cap him at a short-term commitment. The opt-out also fits what Gray has said publicly: he plans to pitch in 2027 but has not committed beyond that, and has talked about stepping away to spend more time with his young family.

There is no draft pick attached on either side. Gray is ineligible for a qualifying offer because he received one from the Twins in 2023, so Minnesota gives up nothing in the signing, and Boston receives no compensation. Gray collected a $10 million buyout when he declined his side of the Red Sox's $30 million mutual option for 2027.

 

 

 

Why Did the Twins Sign Sonny Gray?

Because the rotation was the problem. Minnesota's starters ranked 22nd in the majors in ERA in 2026, according to ESPN, and the injuries piled up: Pablo López missed the entire season after elbow surgery, and Joe Ryan missed about a month late in the year with a glute injury. Ryan, López, Bailey Ober and Dean Kremer are all one year from free agency, and general manager Jeremy Zoll has hinted that the Twins may trade one of them.

Gray gives Minnesota a veteran who has already done it in this building. In 2022 and 2023, he posted a 2.90 ERA over 303.2 innings for the Twins, made an All-Star team and finished second in AL Cy Young voting in 2023, then left for the Cardinals on a three-year, $75 million deal. Chairman Tom Pohlad has said he intends to invest meaningfully in payroll for 2027, and the Twins have already brought back catcher Ryan Jeffers on the $23.15 million qualifying offer this week.

On paper, Gray, Ryan, López, Taj Bradley and Kremer give Minnesota a legitimate top four if López returns healthy. The rotation math also gives the front office flexibility to move a starter without gutting the group.

Sonny Gray 2026 Stats

Gray went 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, and 149 strikeouts over 169 innings in 29 starts for Boston, the lowest ERA of his career in a qualified season. His career line sits at 143-107 with a 3.51 ERA and 2,074 strikeouts over 2,087 innings. The underlying numbers, though, tell a different story from the ERA.

SeasonIPERAFIPK%BB%LOB%
2024 Cardinals166.13.843.1230.3%5.8%67.9%
2025 Cardinals180.24.283.3926.7%5.0%69.6%
2026 Red Sox169.02.723.4721.8%6.7%83.2%
2027 Steamer proj.168.03.813.6523.0%6.5%72.7%

Source: FanGraphs. Projection is Steamer; the FanGraphs depth charts projection is nearly identical (3.81 ERA, 3.65 FIP over 168 innings).

 

 

 

Can Sonny Gray Repeat His 2026 Season?

Probably not at that ERA. His 2.72 mark outran his 3.47 FIP and 3.87 xERA by a wide margin, and the gap is mostly explained by a strand rate of 83.2 percent, far above his 73.6 percent career rate and the 72.7 percent that Steamer projects for 2027. Both FanGraphs projection systems peg him for a 3.81 ERA and a 3.65 FIP, which is a solid number for a mid-rotation starter but not an ace-level one.

The bigger trend is the strikeout rate. Gray struck out 30.3 percent of hitters in 2024, 26.7 percent in 2025 and 21.8 percent in 2026, all while his fastball velocity sat at 91.8 mph, in the 13th percentile. He is succeeding with command and contact management instead: his walk rate (79th percentile), chase rate (77th) and ground ball rate (73rd) all rank well, and his sinker and sweeper each graded as +6 runs against left-handed hitters, per Baseball Savant.

Statcast metric (2026)ValueMLB percentile
Pitching run value15 runs87th
Fastball run value11 runs88th
Breaking run value4 runs74th
xERA3.8760th
Fastball velocity91.8 mph13th
Chase %33.2%77th
Whiff %23.1%33rd
K %21.8%43rd
BB %6.7%79th
Barrel %6.9%59th
Ground ball %46.4%73rd

Source: Baseball Savant 2026 percentile rankings. Percentiles are scaled so that higher is better.

The projections expect some strikeout recovery (a 23.0 percent rate and 162 strikeouts over 168 innings), but his age and velocity make a return to the 2024 level unlikely. The case for optimism is that Gray has shown he can adapt, and he keeps the ball on the ground and limits hard contact well enough (barrel rate in the 59th percentile) to stay effective.

Sonny Gray Fantasy Baseball Impact

Gray is a mid-rotation fantasy starter with ratio upside and a modest strikeout ceiling. The 18 wins and 2.72 ERA are not a baseline to draft on: the projections point to roughly a 3.81 ERA and 162 strikeouts, with about 168 innings. Leaving Boston and the AL East for the AL Central is a friendlier setup on paper, and he has pitched well in Minnesota before, but his value will depend on whether the Twins can supply run support and a steady bullpen behind him.

In strikeout formats, he is more of a volume play than a ceiling play, since his 21.8 percent strikeout rate trails what most fantasy managers want from an SP3. Best-ball and daily fantasy players should price him as a stable floor with some blow-up risk against power-heavy lineups. The opt-out does not affect 2027 fantasy value, but it makes him a one-year rental in dynasty and keeper formats.

 

 

 

Twins Sonny Gray Signing Grade

  • Twins: B. The money is fair for a projected 3.0 WAR starter; there is no draft pick cost, and it fills the Twins' biggest need. The deductions are age 37, a 2026 ERA that is very likely to regress, and the opt-out structure: if Gray pitches well, Minnesota gets one year and he can walk, and if he struggles, the Twins are stuck with year two.
  • Red Sox: Boston loses its 18-game winner without compensation, though the underlying numbers suggest they avoided paying for the peak of his 2026 results.

What's Next for the Twins?

Minnesota still has to decide what to do with Ryan, Ober, Kremer and López, the group Zoll said may include a trade candidate. Gray's arrival gives the Twins the depth to move one of them for lineup help, and they still need upgrades in the bullpen and offense after a 2026 season that ended short of the postseason.

Sonny Gray Signing FAQ

How much is Sonny Gray's contract with the Twins?

Two years and $55 million, an average of $27.5 million per year, according to ESPN's Jeff Passan.

Does Sonny Gray's Twins contract have an opt-out?

Yes. Gray can opt out after the first season, so he could become a free agent again after 2027.

What were Sonny Gray's 2026 stats?

Gray went 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA, 1.15 WHIP and 149 strikeouts in 169 innings over 29 starts for the Red Sox.

Did the Twins lose a draft pick to sign Sonny Gray?

No. Gray is ineligible for a qualifying offer because he received one in 2023, so no draft pick compensation is attached to the signing.

Is Sonny Gray retiring?

No. Gray has said he plans to pitch in 2027 but has not committed beyond that season, which is part of why his contract includes an opt-out.

Check FantasyAlarm.com for continuing free agency coverage and fantasy impact updates.