The MLB playoffs march on, which means another day of top MLB Underdog Pick'em plays for Thursday, October 9th, 2025! If you’re looking to crush your MLB player props and pick'em contests, we’ve got you covered with two strong selections for today’s action. Before we dive in, if you haven’t signed up at Underdog yet, use the promo code ALARM at signup, and you’ll get an instant deposit match up to $1,000 in bonus cash, plus a free pick to parlay with these recommendations. Let’s get into the plays!

 

 

 

Underdog Fantasy MLB Picks: Thursday, 10/9; MLB DFS Projections

Elevate your earnings with Underdog promo code ALARM! Seize this fantastic opportunity by registering today! This exclusive offer grants you a 50% bonus on your first deposit, giving you the chance to earn up to $1,000 in bonus funds. Additionally, new users can take advantage of a 99% discount on a pick!

Don’t let this opportunity slip away to boost your income and enhance your daily fantasy sports experience with our MLB DFS Underdog Fantasy picks. Sign up now to maximize the benefits of this incredible promotion and their MLB DFS projections!

 

 

 

William Contreras Underdog MLB Pick - Higher Than 1.5 Hits+Runs+RBI

Through 12 ABs this postseason, Contreras is slashing .417/.462/.750 with two RBI and four runs scored. Contreras recorded an RBI double against presumed starter Matthew Boyd in Game 1, and along with Boyd’s struggles in Game 1, Milwaukee tagged him for four earned runs in 5.1 IP back on August 19th. As a whole, the Milwaukee offense has fared better against LHP, so Contreras should come to the dish in some advantageous spots this evening.

 

 

 

Brandon Marsh Underdog MLB Pick - Lower Than 1.5 Hits+Runs+RBI

Marsh is hitless in his career against Tyler Glasnow, and Marsh’s end-of-season struggles have carried over into the postseason. He slashed just .212/.278/.364 over the final two weeks of the regular season, and the Philadelphia lefty is just 1-for-9 through three games in October.

Glasnow has been far better at home than on the road in 2025, and during the regular season, he posted a 29.2 K% and .167 BAA vs. left-handed hitters at home. Lastly, he’s been pinch-hit for in two of three games, so no guarantees he plays a full nine innings.

 

 

 

Unlock Your 50% Deposit Match Up To $1000 & More With Underdog Promo Code ALARM

Seize this amazing opportunity to boost your earnings with our MLB DFS Underdog Fantasy picks! Sign up today and apply Underdog Fantasy promo code ALARM to get a 50% deposit match, up to $1,000, along with an incredible 99% Off Pick. 

This exceptional offer gives you extra funds to play with, significantly enhancing your chances of hitting it big. Act now! Take advantage of this exclusive chance to elevate your MLB DFS journey. Start your adventure today using Underdog Fantasy promo code ALARM and reap the rewards!

 

Â