As the 2026 MLB season draws near, fantasy baseball managers find themselves grappling with one of the most challenging positions – catcher. After a cursory glance at our player rankings, the position appears to be deeper than usual,  it still remains as unpredictable as ever, with only a select few dependable options at the forefront and a vast array of uncertainties lurking behind them. 

While standout fantasy baseball catchers like Cal Raleigh and William Contreras offer a sense of security for those willing to make an early investment, the rest of the fantasy baseball catcher landscape is filled with potential breakout candidates, time-share dilemmas and late-round risks. 

 

 

For those who prefer to hold off on selecting a catcher, there's a silver lining: a wave of young talent has emerged in recent seasons. Yet, the ongoing issues of inconsistency and playing-time worries keep fantasy baseball catchers among the trickiest positions to navigate in lineups.

Whether you're aiming for a top-tier game-changer or searching for hidden gems later in the draft, having a solid strategy is essential. To assist you in making informed choices, we’ve put together an extensive array of sleeper selections, draft tactics and player analyses. Dive into our expert insights below to secure an advantage in your league!

*Note: Make sure to save this page, as we will continuously refresh it during Spring Training with the most up-to-date and fantasy baseball projections for catchers!

Fantasy Baseball C: 2026 MLB Catchers

Â