Eli Manning, a highly respected quarterback in the history of the NFL, was surprisingly left out of the 2025 class for enshrinement into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. This decision heated up discussions on the part of fans, sports analysts, and former players who say his omission is a monumental mistake. 

A two-time Super Bowl champion and the leading face of the New York Giants franchise for 16 years, many feel that his arguably impressive career numbers entitle him admission among the elite of the NFL.

 

 

 

Eli Manning Stats & Records: An Incredible Career

Eli Manning's career as a professional is studded with accomplishments that should in all normal circumstances guarantee him an easy first-ballot induction. Among his most celebrated accomplishments, he was named Super Bowl MVP after defeating Tom Brady and the New England Patriots in back-to-back appearances in Super Bowl XLII and Super Bowl XLVI. 

The wins sealed his legacy and eradicated the chances of two would-be dynasty runs for the Patriots, including the epic 2007 undefeated season. In the course of his career, Manning completed some 57,023 passing yards to stand tenth on the all-time list by the year 2025. And he had 366 touchdown passes that place him among baseball's ten best quarterbacks of all time. 

Shut away from the public eye by the raucous scrutiny of one of the toughest media markets in America, he cranked out quite an impressive string of 210 consecutive game starts: the third-longest in NFL history for any quarterback.

 

 

 

Why Eli Manning Actually Isn’t One Of The NFL HOF Snubs In 2025

To detract from Manning's Hall of Fame credentials, critics attempt to offset the argument with an overall .500 record in the regular season, i.e., 117 wins vs. 117 losses. Others point out that he is without any league MVP awards or All-Pro distinctions – indices that are oftentimes outweighed during Hall selections.

These beliefs do not show that Manning possesses greatness in pressure situations and has generally upped his games when it matters the most. What he's done in the playoffs for the Giants during their Super Bowl runs stands as near legendary status. 

He is the all-time leader in road playoff wins with five and has made clutch plays time and again. Many believe that these intangibles far outweigh any inconsistency during the regular season.

 

 

 

Should Eli Manning Be In The Hall Of Fame?

Although deserving inductees might populate the 2025 Hall of Fame class, Manning's omission would flag him as an evolving injustice. The Hall has given its due reckoning to players like Antonio Gates, Jared Allen, Sterling Sharpe, and Eric Allen; but leave out Manning, and you raise eyebrows. 

The Hall explained that the course of voting actually may be swayed by narratives, biases, and the strength of individual classes, all of which help us perhaps try to see why Manning may have slipped from the Gang.

 

 

 

Will Eli Manning Be Elected To The Hall of Fame 2026 Class?

There is an initial disappointment for Eli Manning that he did not make the Hall of Fame class of 2025, especially now that there seems to be no doubt about his induction in due time. The process and politics of the Hall have been anything but orderly, but there's no denying that Manning's achievements and impact stand far beyond reproach.

The 2026 Hall of Fame candidates include some sure-fire nominees such as Drew Brees, Larry Fitzgerald, and Frank Gore. Be it 2026 or post that, a day will come when Manning's momentous occasion in Canton will be unwrapped.

The discussion is ongoing, but for now, Eli Manning's reputation as one of the most clutch quarterbacks in NFL history is solidified, with or without a gold jacket. Still, Manning's being one of the NFL HOF snubs in 2025 serves as a loud reminder of how subjective and controversial Hall of Fame selections may be.