Dynasty leagues are the ultimate test of your football IQ, and in 2025, nailing your league setup and draft strategy is key to building a roster that dominates for years. You’re picking players you could keep for a decade, so let’s make those choices count! 

We’ll cover how to set up your dynasty league for success, then dive into a draft plan to outsmart your league mates. Let’s get to work and build a championship dynasty!

What Is a Dynasty League in Fantasy Football?

Dynasty leagues are fantasy football on overdrive—year-round action where you keep most or all of your players season after season. It’s like running your own NFL franchise: you hold onto stars like Ja'Marr Chase or trade them for future assets. A bad pick or a league that falls apart can haunt you, so let’s set it up right and draft like pros.

Suggestions for Setting Up Your Dynasty League

As a Fantasy Alarm #FAmily member, you’re probably the sharpest mind in your league, so you’re likely the one starting this dynasty. Here’s how to make it fun, fair, and built to last, ranked by importance.

Leaguemates

The golden rule: pick great people. In redraft, you can ditch a bad leaguemate next year. In dynasty, they’re in for the long haul, making trades and decisions that shape the league for years. Choose folks who stay engaged, love to trade, and won’t quit after a rough season. A dynasty league with no trades or trash talk is a total snooze—avoid that at all costs.

Voting

Give your league a voice by voting on details like trade deadlines, bench sizes, or FAAB rules. It’s not just about getting it right—it’s about making everyone feel involved. Voting eases your commissioner duties and sets a fair way to settle disputes. With solid leaguemates, this should be smooth. If someone gripes, just say, “Hey, we voted on it!”

League Dues

Keep dues affordable—$25–$50 works—to avoid owners bailing over a bad team. Dynasty is about bragging rights, not just cash. I suggest collecting two years’ dues upfront (e.g., $50 for a $25 league). The second year acts as a deposit, discouraging owners from tanking and quitting. If they leave, they help find a replacement who pays the entry. Trust your crew? You might skip this, but it’s a smart safety net.

Tanking

Tanking can ruin a league if done wrong. The right way: trade aging vets like Davante Adams (ADP 31) for picks or young talent like Malik Nabers (ADP 8). The wrong way: benching stars to snag a top pick. Enforce a “best lineup” rule—everyone starts their top players. Or use an “ideal lineup” system (best-ball scoring) or an NBA-style draft lottery to curb shady tanking. Keep it competitive.

Dynasty Draft

Start-up drafts are best post-NFL Draft (like now, June 2025), when rosters are set. If drafting before the 2026 NFL Draft, choose between drafting rookie prospects or picks for the rookie draft. I prefer picks—less guesswork before landing spots are known. Know your format before you draft.

Trades

Vetoes are a dynasty killer. Nobody predicts the future—think of Puka Nacua (ADP 7) exploding as a rookie. A trade that seems “unfair” today might be a steal tomorrow. Trust your leaguemates (Tip #1) or boot colluders instead of vetoing. Let owners make their moves—public veto votes just spark drama.

Waivers

Use a Free Agent Auction Budget (FAAB) system over old-school waiver priority. Dynasty decisions are massive—players like Bucky Irving (ADP 22) or Rashid Shaheed (ADP 111) were waiver gems who changed teams for years. FAAB rewards savvy owners who budget wisely, not just whoever’s first in line. You’re a Fantasy Alarm reader, so you’ve got the edge—use it!

Format

Tailor your format, but here’s what I recommend:

  • IR Spots: Add 2–3 IR spots for injured stars so owners don’t have to drop them.
  • Scoring: Half-PPR or full-PPR over standard—standard overvalues RBs and feels dated.
  • Small Leagues (8–10 Teams): Go 2QB or superflex to boost QBs like Josh Allen (ADP 35). Add tight end premium to value TEs like Brock Bowers (ADP 15). Use deep lineups (QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Superflex, 3Flex) to keep it competitive.
  • Medium Leagues (12–14 Teams): Superflex is ideal—avoid 2QB, as 28 starters strain the 32-QB pool. Full PPR expands the player pool. Moderate benches (6–8 spots) help newbies find waiver options but allow strategy.
  • Large Leagues (16+ Teams): Use PPR best ball with taxi squads. Best ball auto-picks your top scorers, simplifying deep formats. Taxi squads (3–4 spots) let you stash prospects like J.J. McCarthy (ADP 130) without roster clog.

Dynasty Draft Strategy - 2025 Fantasy Football

You’ve built the perfect league—now it’s time to dominate the draft. A smart 2025 dynasty strategy will set you up for years of success.

Early Draft

The first few rounds are for young, elite talent with staying power. Ja'Marr Chase (ADP 1, age 25), Justin Jefferson (ADP 3, age 26), or Bijan Robinson (ADP 4, age 23) are no-brainers—stars now with a decade ahead. By Round 3, the young studs thin out, leaving you with unproven prospects like Tetairoa McMillan (ADP 45) or aging vets like Tyreek Hill (ADP 27). Decide your path early.

Middle Rounds

Don’t spend the whole draft chasing a perfect youth-talent balance—it’s a trap that lands you in dynasty purgatory, stuck in 6th place with no title or top picks. After Round 2, commit to a strategy:

After Round 2, read your league’s vibe. If everyone’s going young, scoop win-now value like Mike Evans (ADP 36). If they’re chasing titles, go young with players like Ladd McConkey (ADP 19) and trade for picks. This fuels trades—swap your picks for a rebuilder’s vets or vice versa for a win-win.

Late Rounds

Know your format. In a shallow 10-team league (1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1Flex), low-upside guys like Geno Smith (ADP 158) won’t start. Chase high-upside plays like Michael Penix (ADP 138) or rookie TEs like Colston Loveland (ADP 128). In deeper 14-team leagues with multiple flexes, a vet like Adam Thielen (ADP 149) could be a weekly starter. Save your last pick for a big swing—Shedeur Sanders (ADP 216) could be a future QB1.

Want More from the Draft Guide?