Individual Defensive Player (IDP) leagues are no longer a niche—they’re a full-blown revolution in 2025, and if you’re not ready to draft both sides of the ball, you’re missing out. Adding linebackers, defensive linemen, and defensive backs to your roster makes every snap count, and a smart IDP strategy can give you an edge over your leaguemates. Let’s break down the ins and outs of IDP leagues, from setup to draft strategy, and get you primed to dominate your 2025 IDP fantasy football season!

What Is IDP in Fantasy Football?

IDP leagues take fantasy football to the next level by letting you draft individual defensive players—linebackers (LB), defensive backs (DB), and defensive linemen (DL)—alongside your usual offensive stars (QB, RB, WR, TE, K). It’s like adding holds in fantasy baseball: a whole new pool of players opens up, bringing fresh strategy and excitement. In some leagues, IDPs replace the traditional Team Defense/Special Teams (DST) slot; in others, they complement it. You’ll track points from tackles, sacks, interceptions, and more, making every defensive play a chance to rack up points. Get ready to study both sides of the ball and cheer for your players on every down!

NFL Defensive Schemes

Understanding NFL defensive schemes is key to picking the right IDPs. The two main setups are 4-3 and 3-4, and each impacts player value:

4-3 Scheme: Features four linemen and three linebackers. Defensive ends (DEs) like Aidan Hutchinson (DL1) and middle linebackers like Zaire Franklin (LB1) shine here. DEs rack up sacks, while the middle LB is a tackle machine. All three LBs can produce points, as tackles, interceptions, and passes defended are less spread out.

3-4 Scheme: Uses three linemen and four linebackers. Outside linebackers (OLBs) like T.J. Watt (DL2) are sack kings, as linemen like Jeffery Simmons (DL12) focus on clogging run lanes. Inside LBs and DLs get tackles but fewer big plays. Weakside LBs outscore strongside LBs, who often get blocked by tight ends.

In tackle-heavy leagues, 3-4 inside LBs or 4-3 DLs can still deliver. Generally, 4-3 schemes offer more consistent points across five players (two DEs, three LBs), making them prime targets for your roster.

IDP Fantasy Football Linebackers

Linebackers are the heart of IDP leagues, delivering tackles, interceptions, forced fumbles, passes defended, and even the occasional touchdown. Studs like Zaire Franklin (LB1), Roquan Smith (LB3), and Fred Warner (LB5) are worth grabbing early if available, but the LB pool is deep, so you don’t need to rush. Target “three-down” LBs like Zack Baun (LB2) or Bobby Okereke (LB8), who stay on the field for every snap, maximizing their chances to pile up points. LBs on weaker teams, like Alex Singleton (LB4) on Denver, get more tackle opportunities as their defense is on the field longer. Prioritize 4-3 middle LBs or 3-4 weakside LBs for the best production.

IDP Fantasy Football Defensive Backs

If your league doesn’t split cornerbacks (CBs) and safeties (Ss), always lean toward safeties like Brian Branch (DB1), Jaquan Brisker (DB3), or Kyle Hamilton (DB7). Safeties stuff the run and rack up tackles weekly, offering consistency over CBs, whose interceptions are hit-or-miss. Avoid shutdown corners like Paulson Adebo (DB14)—they’re great in real life but often ignored by QBs, limiting their fantasy value. Rookie CBs like Travis Hunter (DB2) are solid picks, as offenses test them early, leading to tackles and passes defended. Safeties facing run-heavy teams, like Antoine Winfield (DB8) against a ground-and-pound offense, can be gold in tackle-heavy leagues.

IDP Fantasy Football Defensive Linemen

For defensive linemen, focus on defensive ends (DEs) over defensive tackles (DTs) unless your league requires a DT. DEs like Maxx Crosby (DL3), Micah Parsons (DL4), and Nick Bosa (DL7) are sack machines and tackle producers, especially in 4-3 schemes. DTs like Dexter Lawrence II (DL38) or Chris Jones (DL45) can contribute but rarely match DEs’ upside. Grab a top-tier DE like Aidan Hutchinson (DL1) if LBs are gone, as the drop-off after the top 10 DLs (e.g., Myles Garrett, DL10) is steep. Check 2024 sack and tackle stats for guidance, but don’t expect exact repeats—production can vary year to year.

When to Draft IDP

Don’t touch IDPs until your starting offensive lineup (QB, RB, WR, TE) is locked in, plus at least one backup RB and WR. Even then, wait until you’ve got two or three offensive backups before diving into IDPs, unless your league inflates defensive scoring. In most leagues, top LBs like Roquan Smith (LB3) or DLs like T.J. Watt (DL2) will be gone by the time you pick IDPs, but solid DBs (e.g., Budda Baker, DB4) and DLs (e.g., Trey Hendrickson, DL8) often linger. Fill all IDP starting spots before adding more offensive backups, but stay flexible—if a steal like Puka Nacua (WR7, ADP 7) falls late, grab him over a mid-tier IDP. Always draft IDPs before your kicker or DST (if your league uses one), ideally taking DST in the second-to-last round.

IDP Fantasy Scoring

Aim for IDPs to score close to your offensive players—10–15 points weekly from a top LB like Fred Warner (LB5) matches a solid RB or WR. Big-play weeks from players like Micah Parsons (DL4) can even rival QB totals. Default IDP scoring often mirrors DST (tackles, sacks, interceptions), but for a balanced setup, try this hybrid system to reward impact plays:

  • Solo Tackle: 1 point
  • Assisted Tackle: 0.5 points
  • Sack: 4 points
  • Interception: 6 points
  • Pass Defended: 3 points
  • Fumble Forced: 4 points
  • Fumble Recovered: 2 points
  • Safety: 2 points
  • Blocked FG/PAT/Punt: 6 points
  • Defensive TD: 6 points

This values game-changing plays (sacks, interceptions, forced fumbles) over luck-based stats (fumble recoveries). Some leagues skip DST or even kickers, freeing slots for more IDPs or offensive sleepers—consider this for deeper rosters.

The best IDP leagues use 6–8 defensive slots: 2 LBs, 2 DLs, 2 DBs, and 1–2 defensive flex (LB/DB/DL). You could skip dedicated DL slots, letting owners choose via 2–4 general defensive player (DP) slots for flexibility.

IDP Fantasy Football Rookies

Unlike offensive rookies, who often need time to shine, IDP rookies can make an instant impact. Rookie CBs like Travis Hunter (DB2) rack up points as offenses target them early. First-round NFL draft picks like Abdul Carter (DL44) or rookies stepping into starting roles due to trades or retirements offer great value. The learning curve for IDPs is less steep, but plan for backups—rookies may hit a wall late in the season facing NFL vets. Check team depth charts to confirm starting roles before drafting.

IDP Draft Strategy

  • Know Your League Rules: Master your scoring, roster limits, and position eligibility. A tackle-heavy league favors three-down LBs like Blake Cashman (LB6); a big-play league boosts sack artists like Maxx Crosby (DL3). Check if your platform allows dual eligibility (e.g., Micah Parsons as LB/DL) for extra value.
  • Prioritize Offense Early: Fill your starting offensive roster and grab 1–2 backups before drafting IDPs. Don’t reach for a stud LB like Roquan Smith (LB3) over a top-20 offensive player like Bijan Robinson (RB2, ADP 4).
  • Target Consistent Tacklers: Focus on tackles for steady points—4-3 middle LBs (Zaire Franklin, LB1), 3-4 outside LBs (Andrew Van Ginkel, DL5), and safeties (Kyle Hamilton, DB7). Sacks and interceptions are less predictable, except for elite DEs like Aidan Hutchinson (DL1).
  • Draft for Scheme Fit: Prioritize 4-3 DEs (Nick Bosa, DL7) and MLBs (Fred Warner, LB5) or 3-4 OLBs (T.J. Watt, DL2). Avoid 3-4 DLs (Zach Sieler, DL21) or strongside LBs unless tackles are heavily weighted.
  • Value Safeties Over CBs: Safeties like Brian Branch (DB1) offer tackle consistency; avoid shutdown CBs like Paulson Adebo (DB14) unless your league rewards big plays.
  • Mind Position Scarcity: If your league requires DTs, grab one early—Jeffery Simmons (DL12) is a rare stud. LBs are deep, so you can wait on players like Kaden Elliss (LB7).
  • Use the Waiver Wire: IDPs are matchup-driven, especially DBs like Jalen Pitre (DB12). Check schedules—players facing high-powered offenses (e.g., Kevin Byard, DB5) get more tackle chances. Replace underperformers or injured players like Bradley Chubb (DL14, Q) without hesitation.
  • Don’t Fear Bye Week Drops: Unless you have a top-tier IDP like Maxx Crosby (DL3), drop them for bye weeks—others won’t snag them, or you’ll find comparable replacements like Jonathon Cooper (DL35) on waivers.

IDP Rankings: Fantasy Football 2025

Check out Fantasy Alarm’s 2025 IDP rankings for a full breakdown, but here’s a sneak peek at the top players to target:

Adapt these to your league’s scoring—tackle-heavy setups boost LBs like Bobby Okereke (LB8), while big-play leagues favor DLs like Trey Hendrickson (DL8). Stay tuned to Fantasy Alarm’s weekly IDP Reports for updates on risers, fallers, and waiver targets.

IDP Fantasy Football Strategy: Final Thoughts

Consistency is king in IDP leagues. Draft for tackles: 4-3 middle LBs (Zaire Franklin, LB1), 3-4 outside LBs (T.J. Watt, DL2), 4-3 DEs (Nick Bosa, DL7), and safeties (Kyle Hamilton, DB7). Sacks and interceptions are bonuses, not guarantees, except for elite DEs like Aidan Hutchinson (DL1). Target tacklers on weaker teams—LBs like Alex Singleton (LB4) on Denver get more snaps against high-volume offenses. Conversely, DBs like Brian Branch (DB1) on stronger teams face pass-heavy opponents, boosting tackle and interception chances.

The waiver wire is your best friend—IDP production fluctuates with matchups, injuries, and roles. Don’t sweat missing top DBs like Budda Baker (DB4); players like Jalen Pitre (DB12) can emerge midseason. If your league scores return yards, snag IDPs like Travis Hunter (DB2) who double as kick returners for extra points.

IDP leagues make every game electric—you’ll be glued to Monday night when your LB like Roquan Smith (LB3) seals a win with a tackle barrage. Take the plunge into IDP in 2025, and you’ll never go back to offense-only leagues. 

Want More from the Draft Guide?