Fantasy baseball pitching matchups: is there a more important yet more unpredictable aspect of winning in your daily fantasy lineups? 

That's exactly why Fantasy Alarm is proud to introduce Fantasy Baseball Daily Pitching Matchup Rating Grid: a game-changing tool to arm you with the edge you need to destroy the competition. 

 

 

 

What is the MLB Pitching Matchup Grid? It is a simple yet powerful go-to tool for evaluating starting pitchers each day of the season. 

We will not just give the starters for the day; instead, we will take a deep dive into various important metrics such as opposing team batting statistics, pitcher ERA, strikeout rates, park factors, and weather conditions in order to deliver a thorough rating for every matchup. 

In the ever-changing world of fantasy baseball starting pitchers, there is daily movement with rising aces ascending the 2025 list and aging stars taking on new challenges. 

In fact, it becomes a critical component of DFS lineup selection, spotting sleepers, or steering clear of potential disasters. 

The colors in the rating scale will signify the matchups in the following way: 

  • GREEN - Elite Arms that will face more conducive conditions and thus possess high upside.
  • YELLOW - Slightly riskier plays, but they could have the upside of getting the win.
  • ORANGE - Plays that should be approached with caution.
  • RED - Those facing difficult matchups or in risky environments.

 

Updated: 8/30/2025

PitcherTeamMatchupKey Stats
Logan GilbertSeattle MarinersCleveland GuardiansWe don't sit our aces at this time of year.
Tyler GlasnowLos Angeles DodgersArizona DiamondbacksAgain, we don't sit our aces.
Nick PivettaSan Diego PadresMinnesota TwinsMaybe not a true ace, but we don't sit him against the Twinkies.
Cristopher SanchezPhiladelphia PhilliesAtlanta BravesWill bounce back from last start to prove he's still an ace.
Trevor RogersBaltimore OriolesSan Francisco GiantsNine straight QS? Did someone pop Rogers into a video game or something?
Andrew AbbottCincinnati RedsSt. Louis CardinalsHitting some speed bumps, but still very startable against the Cardinals.
David PetersonNew York MetsMiami MarlinsMiami lineup is just plain awful.
Cam SchlittlerNew York YankeesChicago White SoxGood stuff, good command, and the White Sox are also awful.
Ryan PepiotTampa Bay RaysWashington NationalsRoad start against a middling offense works for us today.
Edward CabreraMiami MarlinsNew York MetsNot much win equity given the lack of run support, but still startable.
Merrill KellyTexas RangersAthleticsNot a fan of the Sacramento start, but willing to give a look.
Jack FlahertyDetroit TigersKansas City RoyalsNot a tough lineup to face, but Flaherty's been roughed up hard lately.
Kevin GausmanToronto Blue JaysMilwaukee BrewersWe should be able to get five innings here with minimal damage...we hope.
Spencer ArrighettiHouston AstrosLos Angeles AngelsStrikeout upside but the command has been rough upon his return.
Gavin WilliamsCleveland GuardiansSeattle MarinersCommand issues been dogging him lately.
Quinn PriesterMilwaukee BrewersToronto Blue JaysStart was pushed back with a wrist issue. Not sure we can trust him.
Chris SaleAtlanta BravesPhiladelphia PhilliesJust off the 60-day IL and now getting the Phillies? Not yet.
Taj BradleyMinnesota TwinsSan Diego PadresNot sure they made the right choice pushing Mick Abel to the pen. Tough to trust Bradley after watching the White Sox have their way with him.
Michael McGreevySt. Louis CardinalsCincinnati RedsInteresting streamer if he keeps the ground ball rate high. Need ERA to give if you're giving this one a try.
Shane SmithChicago White SoxNew York YankeesLost command of his secondary offerings. Yankees should take advantage.
Javier AssadChicago CubsColorado RockiesLike the picther, do not like Coors Field.
Eduardo RodriguezArizona DiamondbacksLos Angeles DodgersNot someone to trust at this time of year, especially against the Dodgers.
Jake IrvinWashington NationalsTampa Bay RaysHe's just not good. 15 ER allowed over last 12.1 IP should say enough.
Johan OviedoPittsburgh PiratesBoston Red SoxInconsistent command and the Sox have eyes on the playoffs.
Dustin MayBoston Red SoxPittsburgh PiratesYes, it's the Pirates but May hasn't looked good since the trade that sent him to Boston.
Kyle HendricksLos Angeles AngelsHouston AstrosNever.
Stephen KolekKansas City RoyalsDetroit TigersThere's just not enough here to make it worth the risk.
Carson SeymourSan Francisco GiantsBaltimore OriolesGood velo, but minimal win equity and spotty command.
Mason BarnettAthleticsTexas RangersCalled up to pitch in Sacramento? Nope.
McCade BrownColorado RockiesChicago CubsCool name but no chance.